Woman abducted 51 years ago and reunited with family reveals horrid childhood

The Texas woman that was abducted 51 years ago by the babysitter shared her horrific childhood and the sexual abuse she endured by her stepfather before she became a teen runaway living on the streets to survive, DailyMail.com can now reveal.

Melissa Highsmith now 53 was miraculously reunited with her biological parents – Jeffrie Higshmith, 72; Alta Alpantenco, 73 and siblings – Rebecca Del Bosque, 48; Vicitoria Highsmith, 47; Sharon Highsmith, 45 and Jeffrey Highsmith, 42 – on November 26- five decades after she was abducted in 1971 when she was only 22 months old. 

Melissa said she has no doubt in her mind that the person she called ‘mama’ was the same person who abducted her. 

‘Before I met my new family I reached out to the mother that I thought raised me and asked her if there was something she needed to tell me. She told me she had  purchased me on the street for $500.’ 

‘I was shocked. My head was spinning. I didn’t sleep. She never told me,’ Melissa said, ‘but she always told me that she had something to tell me that she had been wanting to tell me for a long time that is when I told her I already knew.’

According to Melissa’s family members the woman who posed as Melissa’s mother was identified as Patricia ‘Sugar’ Lewis, who now lives in Missouri.

Precious time she will never get back, a lost childhood, time away from her parents and siblings, but Melissa told DailyMail.com that ‘she doesn’t want to focus on the anger.’ 

 ‘I am still angry but I am going to focus on the happiness that is to come not the pain that I left,’ she said. ‘God got this done and I have to focus on going forward.’

The criminal statue of limitations expired 20 years ago when Melissa was 18, but her family is now determined to change the laws. 

Melissa added: ‘I don’t want her to go to jail I just want her to be held accountable and to say, ‘I’m sorry.’

But, younger sibling Rebecca Del Bosque told DailyMail.com she feels differently: ‘She stole a sibling from us we never knew, a child from her parents, there is no justice for us at all.’

She added: ‘We need to find out if her siblings were kidnapped too. Right now we have no idea.’

As her family spent decades looking for their family member, Melissa whose name was changed to Melanie was barely surviving.

She shared with DailyMail.com some of the hardship and horror she endured at the hands of the woman she thought was her mother and her stepfather – having no idea she was adopted until a week ago – and had this giant family searching for her.

‘I thought she was my real mom but I thought she regretted having me. There was no closeness… no love. She told me all of my life I was brain damaged and I was mentally retarded,’ she said. 

Melissa said when she was a child her mother had put her in special classes despite her teachers telling her that she did not belong in them. She said that her two other siblings, a younger and older brother, had lived with her too. She recalled her older brother, who she said she wasn’t close too, getting treated differently than she and her younger brother.

 ‘My dad was very abusive to us. My little brother ended up moving in with my grandma and then it was just me and my stepfather,’ she said. ‘My mother was emotionally abusive and my stepfather was sexually abusive.’

She told DailyMail.com that she never got pregnant during the years of abuse and said when she was 15 years old she ran away from home.

Melissa and her birth mother are overjoyed that they have found one after 51 years now they plan to spend the rest of their lives getting to know each other again  

See also  South Korea 'heart-throb' Cho Gue-sung has to turn his phone OFF at the World Cup

Melissa meets her parents- her dad Jeffrie Highsmith, 72 and mother Alta Altanpanco, 73 for the first time since she was kidnapped August 23, 1971 when she was 22 months old 

A black and white composite sketch of the babysitter from the 1970s – identified as Ruth Johnson. The mother’s roommate, who handed baby Melissa to the babysitter told the authorities she was wearing a bonnet and white gloves

‘I tried to runaway when I was 14, but it was unsuccessful. I didn’t have nowhere to go so it was easy for them to track me but the second time I had somewhere to go. When they found me the police came to get me and I told them I wasn’t going back so I never went back.’  

She and her high school sweetheart, she described as her ‘first love,’ married and the pair had a rough time of it and were living on and off the streets.   

Texas records show she was arrested at least four times and charged with misdemeanors related to prostitution, The Washington Post reported. 

‘I did things I didn’t want to do,’ she told DailyMail.com ‘but I supported me and my husband.’ 

By the time she was 19, she was a mother of three but, said her children were taken away from her and put up for adoption- two boys and a girl.  She said she had her tubes tied after that and was no longer able to have children.

After leaving her first husband she started working in a host of different jobs from working at a bar, to a few fast food joints, and waitressing to support herself. 

She married again. Her husband, she said, was in and out of prison most of the time. They were together for 16 years and she finally left him because of his addiction.  

Eventually, Melissa found love again with a new man. She said they had a ‘good marriage,’ and were together for ten years but it ended, she said, after he fell into addiction

‘I couldn’t go down the walk he was walking so I chose to go another path,’ she said. 

Undated photos of Melissa from the time she was a child to a teen and as a young woman 

A photo of Melissa with her younger sibling. It is not clear if the adult in the picture is the woman that Melissa claimed was the person she called ‘mama’ most of her life and the one who abducted her 

During this period, she became more religious and relied on her faith to get her through and started cleaning churches and eventually people’s homes to earn some income. A job that she proudly says, she still does today.

 ‘I had PTSD from things that happened in my past so I couldn’t really work around a lot of crowds so I started the cleaning business so I could do one-on-one which was easier for me.’

‘It keeps me busy. I do two or three jobs a day,’ she said.  

Earlier this year, Melissa married her soul mate a man named John Brown she wed in April 2022.

On November 27, Brown posted on Facebook the emotional reunion that took place when  Melissa met her birth mother for the first time.

 ‘This is my beautiful wife Melissa Brown meeting her mother for the first time in 51 years,’ he wrote.

In the video, the pair embrace and sob in each other’s arms.

‘I have seen all the pictures of when we were young,’ Melissa says to her mom.

Her mother removes her sunglasses to get a better look of her long lost daughter, and responds:   ‘I used to be young and beautiful. I changed getting old,’ she said, ‘And missed all these years with you. Maybe we can get to know each other better.’

Melissa asks: You live in Forth Worth?’

‘I live in Forth Worth,’ her mother says. ‘Seventeen minutes away from you.’ 

During the tear-jerking meeting, the video captures her meeting her father and one of her cousins named Melissa, who she learned was named after her, for the first time.

In April 2022, Melissa found her soul mate, a man she had met in church, John Brown. The couple wed in April 2022

Melissa hugging her dad for the first time as her mother tearfully looks ahead

The Facebook post the family sent out when Melissa was ‘found.’ The image shows Alta, as a young mother holding up the newspaper story when Melissa first went missing 

Melissa pictured with her baby brother, Jeffrey, 42, who has been searching for his big sister most of his life 

Melissa (left) and another sibling Victoria Highsmith, 47, (right). Both siblings have their own cleaning businesses and both love to donate to charity 

Rebeca told DailyMail.com how she joined websleuth and was always trying to find Melissa and between 2005 and 2007 thought she came close but was heartbroken when she learned after a DNA test that the person she thought maybe her sister wasn’t, after all.

‘When the DNA came back and it wasn’t our sister it was pretty devastating because I had built a connection with her,’ Rebecca said. ‘I just couldn’t put myself in my heart out like that.’

She said her brother Jeff and sister-in-law created a Facebook page and started their own investigation.

In September 2022, everything changed when Rebecca and Sharon Highsmith learned that their had been a possible sighting in Charleston, South Carolina of the their sister. That lead, although it ended up being a dead end, gave the family renewed hope.       

Melissa Highsmith (pictured) was kidnapped by a babysitter in 1971 at just 22-months-old

The Missing person flyer the family distributed when Melissa was missing 

A picture of baby Melissa and a computer-generated photo of Melissa as an adult 

Jeff, 42, told DailyMail.com in a prior interview that he was only six years old when his parents told him about his sister Melissa Highsmith’s abduction.

He said at the time he was too young to understand, but around thirteen he began to do his own research and became obsessed with her disappearance.

‘It was a horrible tragedy and we never thought we would find her and we just moved on but it haunted me and consumed me,’ Jeff said.    

He said his mother was only 20 years old when his sister was abducted, and his father, 19 and had left his mother to run off with another woman. He said, his parents eventually reunited to help find their missing child.

In an emotional clip filmed on Thanksgiving, Melissa was seen hugging her mother and father for the first time in over 50 years – as the parents embraced their beloved long-lost daughter.

Jeff said each year the family would celebrate Melissa’s birthday. During the last birthday they spent without her, Melissa’s father told the Fort Worth Star-Telegram: ‘We are looking for her and still care.’

Later that day the family uncovered a lead that would unify them with her just weeks later, after decades of agony.

It was brought about by a DNA test and detective work by Lisa Jo Schiele, a clinical laboratory scientist and amateur genealogist who encouraged the family to try a 23andMe DNA test.

Melissa’s father submitted a DNA sample to 23andMe, which returned a 100 percent match with three people. Those three people were the children of Joe Brown and his wife Melanie – one of which was Melissa.

‘It’s overwhelming and incredible to me,’ said Sharon Highsmith, Melissa’s younger sister.

‘For decades, my parents have chased leads, hiring their own labs and investigators and yet, these DNA tests, which are available to anyone, helped us find our lost loved one.’

Melissa said she would be changing her name officially to reflect the one she was given at birth. 

‘Now that we have Melissa home all of us are going to be together – the grandkids the great grandkids, the great nephews for Christmas,’ he said. ‘We haven’t all been together in 20 years.’ 

Jeff explained that when Melissa went missing on August 23, 1971 his mother was a single mom and needed help with childcare while she worked as a waitress. 

After putting up an advertisement in the local newspaper he said a woman who identified herself as Ruth Johnson, responded.

He said the woman agreed to meet his mother at the restaurant she worked at, but never showed up. 

Then the potential babysitter called up again insisting she was right for the job.

‘She said, you know, I really love kids and I’ve got this huge backyard and the kids love to play out there, and I was desperate, I needed a babysitter because I was supporting myself,’ Apantenco told Fox4 in 2019.

Melissa had been in the care of her mother’s roommate, with whom she was living in the Spanish Gate Apartments on East Seminary Drive in Fort Worth, who then handed Melissa over to the unknown babysitter.

On that hot August day in 1971 would be the last time anyone would ever see baby Melissa again.

After she was reported missing, the roommate told the authorities that the mysterious woman who picked up baby Melissa was wearing white gloves and a bonnet on her head. 

‘My mom did the best she could with the limited resources she had. She couldn’t risk getting fired. So, she trusted the person who said they’d care for her child,’ Sharon Highsmith, Melissa’s sister said.

‘For 50 years, my mom has lived with the guilt of losing Melissa. She’s also lived with community and nationwide accusations that she hurt or killed her own baby. 

‘I’m so glad we have Melissa back. I’m also grateful we have vindication for my mom.’

Sharon now lives in Spain and although she has never met Melissa she is looking forward to doing so this Christmas. 

Jeff told DailyMail.com that the Forth Worth Police Department, Tarrant County and the FBI were looking at his mother in connection with his sister’s disappearance.

‘The police never took the investigation off of my mom. They always thought my mom had something to do with it and they didn’t pursue anything else,’ he said.

‘I didn’t understand. There was no justification. It was frustrating,’ he said. ‘From what I was told, in 1971 it was a different time for women. It was a time when Roe vs. Wade and the women’s movement and women weren’t treated as equal as me

Earlier this year in October the family were lead to Charleston, South Carolina to investigate a tip that Melissa had been seen there.  

She was identified based on a computer generated prediction of what Melissa would look like fifty years on from her baby photos.

When the family got there they were faced with disappointment. That’s when the they stared thinking about DNA tests and were connected with her children.

‘We had coffee with her on Thanksgiving night, and when I looked at her, I just knew. I knew,’ Jeff Highsmith said, adding later that he ‘couldn’t take’ his eyes off her when they met because she looked ‘just like’ his mother, he told Fox.

‘Our family has suffered at the hands of agencies who have mismanaged this case,’ Sharon said.

‘Right now, we just want to get to know Melissa, welcome her to the family and make up for 50 years of lost time.’

Sharon, her siblings and their parents encouraged other families with missing loved ones to keep on believing.